The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) and the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) oversee India’s extensive tax system. In India, taxes are often divided into two categories: direct taxes and indirect taxes. Direct taxes are charged directly on an individual’s or organization’s income or wealth, such as income tax and corporate tax, while indirect taxes are imposed on goods and services, like GST and customs duty, and are paid by consumers as part of the purchase price.
Taxes are an important source of government revenue in India, funding infrastructure, defense, education, and social services. The country features a dual taxation system, which allows both the central and state governments to impose taxes.
India’s Tax Structure
India’s tax system is separated into two categories: direct and indirect taxes, which are administered by both the central and state governments.
- Direct Taxes
- Levied directly on individuals, companies, and organizations based on income or profits.
- Examples include Income Tax, Corporate Tax, and Capital Gains Tax.
- Generally progressive, meaning higher incomes are taxed at higher rates.
- Indirect Taxes
- Levied on goods and services rather than on income.
- Paid by consumers as part of the price of goods or services.
- Examples include Goods and Services Tax (GST), customs duty, and excise duty.
If you want to know more about income tax rules, read our blog about Income tax rules for freelancers.
Why So Much Tax in India
Taxes in India may appear excessive because they are the government’s principal source of revenue, funding critical services and development projects. Tax revenue is utilized for the following purposes:
- Infrastructure: Building roads, bridges, railways, and urban development.
- Defense and Security: Maintaining the army, navy, air force, and internal security.
- Education and Health: Funding schools, universities, hospitals, and public health programs.
- Social Welfare: Supporting poverty alleviation, subsidies, pensions, and other social schemes.
Furthermore, India has a dual taxation structure (central and state), which can give the impression that taxes are higher because they are levied by several governmental levels. The tax system also comprises both direct taxes (income, corporation tax) and indirect taxes (GST, customs duty), which add up to the total tax burden.
Tax Comparison: India vs Other Countries
| Country | Top Personal Income Tax Rate | Corporate Tax Rate | VAT / GST | Tax-to-GDP Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
India |
30% |
25–30% |
5–28% GST |
~17–18% |
|
USA |
37% |
21% |
Varies by state, ~4–10% |
~26–27% |
|
Canada |
33% |
15–26.5% |
5–15% GST/HST |
~33% |
|
UK |
45% |
19% |
20% VAT |
~33–34% |
Even while India’s overall tax burden is modest when compared to developed countries, the country’s reliance on indirect taxes like GST makes routine transactions appear more costly.
Does Middle Class Pay More Taxes Than Rich in India
In India, the tax system is progressive, which means that higher-earning persons are expected to pay a bigger proportion of their income in taxes. The wealthy are often taxed more heavily, and the middle class pays moderately.
However, in practice, many middle-class taxpayers end up contributing a considerable share of the overall personal income tax.
Many wealthy people use exemptions, deductions, and investment options to lower their taxable income.
The majority of middle-class Indians make taxable wages and do not have enough exemptions to drastically lower their taxes.
Indirect taxes such as GST, fuel tax, and customs duty affect everyone equally, which means that middle-class households generally bear the majority of the financial burden.
Why Can’t India Adopt a Tax-Free Model Like the UAE?
The concept of a tax-free economy is attractive, but it is not possible for a country like India due to significant disparities in revenue sources, demography, and governance as compared to the United Arab Emirates (UAE).
- Revenue Sources
- UAE: The UAE’s economy is primarily reliant on oil and natural gas revenues, which have historically supplied a massive, consistent income for the government. Despite the UAE’s diversification into tourism, real estate, and banking, oil exports keep funding public infrastructure, welfare programs, and government operations, enabling the country to maintain low or no personal income taxes.
- India: India, on the other hand, does not have as much money from natural resources. Its government primarily funds development initiatives, public services, military, education, healthcare, and welfare programs through taxation, which includes income tax, corporation tax, and Goods and Services Tax (GST). The Indian government would find it difficult to provide for the demands of its sizable population without taxes.
- Demographics
- UAE: Although there are only about 10 million people living in the United Arab Emirates, about 90% of them are foreigners who support the country’s economy through work permits, taxes, and consumer spending. The government can more easily control revenue and expenditures without imposing high taxes because of the small population.
- India: On the other hand, India is the most populous democracy in the world, with a population of over 1.4 billion. A large and diverse population depends on the government for basic services like welfare, public healthcare, education, roads, and defense. Without a consistent flow of tax income, these programs would be hard to sustain.
- Governance & Economic Structure
- UAE: The UAE has a centralized governance model based on a federation of emirates, with extensive control over natural and financial resources. This enables efficient revenue management without excessive taxation.
- India: India is a federal democracy with a shared budget between the federal and state governments. Each level of government needs funding to function properly, which involves a structured tax system. Furthermore, India’s emphasis on inclusive growth, social welfare, and poverty reduction necessitates significant recurring revenue streams that cannot be met only through non-tax sources.
Final Thoughts
While it may appear like India charges excessive taxes, these contributions are what keep the country moving forward by funding infrastructure, education, healthcare, and social development. The goal is not just to pay taxes, but to comprehend how they affect our economy and daily life. We at Team Taxperts, the best financial advisor in Kerala, assist people and companies in effectively navigating India’s intricate tax structure, guaranteeing compliance while optimizing advantages. After all, effective tax planning is the first step toward financial independence and national progress.